Erie v. Moore, McCutcheon
Year 2018
Court Superior Court of Pennsylvania
Case Number No. WAP 2018
Issue
  • Duty to Defend
State
  • Pennsylvania

Insurance companies may not preemptively discern an intent to cause injury when a complaint alleges accidental injury to nullify the insurer’s duty to defend. The point of the duty to defend is ensure that the policyholder has a defense to potentially covered allegations pending a determination of the actual facts. UPdate: UP was able to secure a favorable decision in this case. Find the opinion and dissent below.

Related Docs
Author John N. Ellison, Esq. and Timothy P. Law, Esq.
Related Cases
Aloha Petroleum v. National Union Fire Insurance Company
Year: 2024
Court: Hawaii Supreme Court
Case Number: SCCQ-23-0000515
Issue:
  • Duty to Defend
State:
  • Hawaii

In the Aloha Petroleum case, the Hawaii Supreme Court accepted a certified question from a Hawaii Federal District Court asking: (1) For any insurance policy defining a covered “occurrence” in part as an “accident,” can an “accident” include recklessness? and (2) For an “occurrence” insurance…
Hartford Fire Insurance Company v. Medline Industries, Inc. et al.
Year: 2023
Court: Appellate Court of Illinois, First Judicial District
Case Number: 1-23-0841
Issue:
  • Duty to Defend
State:
  • Illinois

In its amicus curiae brief, United Policyholders addresses the question of whether a liability insurer has a duty to defend an underlying lawsuit alleging only willful and intentional wrongdoing by an insured defendant but when liability could be established by proof of non-intentional, accidental conduct. Drawing…
Travelers Insurance Company, et al. v. Bodell Construction Company
Year: 2023
Court: Hawaii Supreme Court
Case Number: SCCQ-22-0000658
Issue:
  • Duty to Defend
State:
  • Hawaii

In its amicus brief, United Policyholders addresses a critical question that has split state high courts around the country: whether an insurance company can seek reimbursement or recoupment of previously paid defense fees and costs when the insurance policy contains no express provision allowing for…
QBE Insurance Corporation v. The Eighth Judicial District Court of the State of Nevada and Lamplight Village @ Centennial Springs Homeowners Association
Year: 2022
Court: Nevada Supreme Court
Case Number: 84181
Issue:
  • Duty to Defend
State:
  • Nevada

In its amicus curiae brief, United Policyholders addresses the special and ongoing obligations imposed on an insurance company that has undertaken the legal defense of its insured in an underlying tort lawsuit.